Breaking News: Trump Barred From Denying Abuse at Carroll Defamation Trial

In yet another dramatic turn of events, former US President Donald Trump has been barred from denying accusations of sexual abuse at the defamation trial of E. Jean Carroll. This marks a significant blow to Trump’s ongoing legal battles and highlights the continued impact of the #MeToo movement.

For those unfamiliar with the case, E. Jean Carroll alleges that Trump raped her in a department store dressing room in the mid-1990s. Trump has vehemently denied the allegations, going so far as to claim that he had never even met Carroll (despite a photo of the two of them together surfacing). In response, Carroll filed a defamation lawsuit against Trump, arguing that by calling her a liar and claiming she made the whole thing up, he had damaged her professional reputation and caused her emotional distress.

The case has been winding its way through the court system for years, with Trump’s legal team arguing that he cannot be sued for defamation because he made the statements in his official capacity as President. However, in March 2021, the US Supreme Court ruled that the case could proceed, paving the way for a potential trial.

And now, with the trial fast approaching, Trump has been dealt another blow. On August 12th, US District Judge Lewis A. Kaplan ruled that Trump cannot argue that Carroll’s allegations are false and defamatory because doing so would essentially require him to accuse her of lying. This is because defamation law in the US has a “truth” defense – that is, if someone accuses you of something and you can prove that it’s true, you can’t be sued for defamation.

However, in this case, Judge Kaplan ruled that Trump could not use the truth defense because the alleged rape happened so long ago that there is no way to definitively prove whether it did or did not occur. This means that, at the trial, Trump will not be able to argue that he didn’t rape Carroll or that her allegations are false. Instead, he will have to argue that he had the right to call her a liar and that his statements did not actually damage her reputation.

As you can imagine, this ruling has left Trump and his legal team scrambling. In a statement to the media, Trump’s spokesperson Jason Miller claimed that the ruling was “unprecedented and outrageous” and that it “should send shivers down the spine of any American who believes in the First Amendment.” However, legal experts have pointed out that Judge Kaplan’s ruling is actually in line with previous defamation cases where the truth defense was unavailable for various reasons.

Regardless of how you feel about the ruling, there’s no denying that the upcoming trial is going to be a tense, high-stakes affair. It’s not often that a former President finds themselves in the dock, accused of sexual assault. Indeed, apart from this case, the only other time that a former US President has been sued for defamation was when Bill Clinton was sued by Paula Jones in 1994 (Jones alleged that Clinton made sexual advances towards her while he was Governor of Arkansas).

Of course, there are some key differences between the Trump and Clinton cases. For one thing, Clinton’s case revolved around his conduct while he was still Governor, whereas Trump’s alleged rape occurred before he ever entered politics. Additionally, Clinton settled the case out of court for $850,000, whereas Trump has maintained his innocence and is preparing to fight the accusations in court.

But regardless of these differences, there is no denying that both cases highlight the ongoing issue of sexual misconduct in the highest echelons of American politics. As we have seen time and time again, powerful men have been able to get away with sexual assault and harassment for years, protected by their wealth and influence. However, the #MeToo movement has changed all that, shining a light on the systemic misogyny and inequality that pervades our society.

And while Trump may be fighting tooth and nail to clear his name, the fact remains that these accusations have had a lasting impact on his legacy. As more and more women come forward with stories of sexual abuse at the hands of powerful men, it becomes increasingly clear that no one is above the law – not even former Presidents.

In conclusion, the ruling barring Donald Trump from denying accusations of sexual abuse at the defamation trial of E. Jean Carroll marks a major setback for the former President. Regardless of the outcome of the trial, the fact that Trump finds himself in this position underscores the ongoing issue of sexual misconduct among the highest echelons of American politics. The #MeToo movement has shown that no one is above the law, and the upcoming trial will be a testament to that fact. Stay tuned for more updates on this gripping legal saga.


Join The Discussion

Compare listings

    Your Cart
    Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop